Mysterious disappearance
“Looking for that needle in a haystack”: 19 years on, Jennifer Kesse’s disappearance still shocks
In January 2006, 24-year-old financial analyst Jennifer Kesse vanished. Nearly two decades on, the search for answers continues.

On a winter evening in early 2006, Orlando woman Jennifer Kesse came home from work, spoke to her boyfriend on the phone… and then vanished.
Ever since, Kesse’s disappearance has baffled her family, her friends and detectives alike. It’s not only law enforcement that continues to seek out that one clue that might finally crack open the case; Jennifer’s parents, Joyce and Drew, have also unleashed a team of private investigators on a puzzling mystery that has now endured for nearly two full decades. This week marks 19 years since the question was first posed: where is Jennifer Kesse?
And there are hordes of armchair detectives eager to find the answer to that question, too. Alongside other major missing-persons cases to have emerged in the US in recent years - such as the disappearances of Maura Murray, Brian Shaffer and Brandon Swanson - Kesse’s is a head-scratcher that has developed into a deep obsession for amateur sleuths across the true-crime community.
What do we know about Kesse’s disappearance?
Kesse, a 24-year-old financial analyst, disappeared at some point between the evening of Monday January 23 and the morning of Tuesday January 24, 2006.
On the Monday, she had returned to work after a short getaway with her boyfriend, a British man named Rob Allen, whom she had been dating for about a year. The pair had spent the weekend on the Caribbean island of Saint Croix. After work - Kesse was a financial manager at the Central Florida Investments Timeshare Company - she talked on the phone with her parents, with whom she had a close relationship. Later that evening, Allen was the last known person to speak to her, in a call that took place at about 10:00 p.m.
It was on the Tuesday morning that the alarm was raised, when Kesse failed to show up at the office. This was highly out of character for her.
When it emerged that Kesse and Allen had quarreled during their phone conversation on the Monday night, officers at the Orlando Police Department (OPD) initially wondered whether she had taken off after their call, upset over the argument. Would she be back after clearing her head? Speaking to the TV documentary 48 Hours, Allen revealed that the couple had had a “disagreement” as the strain of maintaining a long-distance relationship took its toll. He lived in Fort Lauderdale, some 200 miles away from Orlando.
However, Kesse’s parents insisted to the OPD that their daughter, a person who kept in regular contact with friends and family, would never go off the grid like this.
“That’s not how our daughter’s brain works”
When OPD finally declared Kesse missing, investigators came up against a lack of clear-cut leads. There was no sign of a struggle or forced entry at her home, a condominium she had recently bought at a complex called the Mosaic at Millenia, located in the south of Orlando.
Kesse’s condo offered up persuasive evidence that she had slept in her bed, got up, and prepared for work on the Tuesday morning. Drew explained to WFTV Channel 9: “We do know that she did take a shower, she did get ready for work, she did take her things for work, her towel was wet.”
Kesse’s purse, keys and cell phone were not at her condo; if she was abducted, it seems she was not inside her home when it happened.
In spite of the signs that Kesse had been in her condo on the Tuesday morning, police are said to have briefly chased down an initial theory - prompted by misleading phone tower data - that she might have been abducted while out and about in Orlando after speaking to Allen on the Monday night.
But Drew and Joyce, who described Jennifer as a “creature of habit” in an interview on the Unconcluded podcast, stressed to law enforcement that their daughter always stuck to a consistent midweek routine. It was very unlikely that she would have been anywhere but at home so late in the evening on the day before work.
“Police kept insisting that Jennifer went out in the middle of the night,” Joyce told 48 Hours. “And we’re like: ‘You don’t understand, that’s not how our daughter’s brain works.‘" Joyce added: “We, all along, have felt that she was abducted in the morning.”
“She got to her car, and that’s when things went bad”
Joel Wright, an OPD detective assigned as the case’s lead investigator six months after the disappearance, agrees. In an interview with WFTV Channel 9, he theorized that she was attacked at some point soon after she left her front door on the Tuesday morning. “From the information I’ve gotten, and the information I trust, she got ready for work, she made it out of her door, she got to her car, and that’s when things went bad,” Wright said. “That’s where I think it happened.”
Kesse’s car found - but unidentified driver gets “luckiest of all lucky breaks”
Kesse’s car, a black Chevrolet Malibu, was initially nowhere to be found. Two days after her disappearance was first reported, however, the vehicle was tracked down. It was parked at the Huntington on the Green, an apartment complex just over a mile away from the Mosaic at Millenia.
And, in what one might expect would lead to a major break in the case, it emerged that there was surveillance footage of the person who drove it there. CCTV images had captured the car arriving at the Huntington on the Green around midday on the Tuesday, before an individual could be seen getting out of the vehicle and striding away, in full view of a surveillance camera.
But it remains a mystery who this person was, as they benefited from a combination of rudimentary CCTV technology and extreme good fortune.
In 2006, the security camera at the Huntington on the Green did not record continuous footage, but instead took grainy, black-and-white stills every couple of seconds. Infuriatingly for investigators, the only snapshots captured by the camera were taken at the precise point when the individual was behind thick fence posts that completely obscured their face.
“Whoever this person is got the luckiest of all lucky breaks,” concludes Nic Edwards, the co-host of the True Crime Garage podcast, which released a four-part series on Jennifer’s disappearance in 2020. Edwards’ co-presenter, known only as ‘The Captain’, agreed: “Even if you paid somebody to try to recreate this, you probably couldn’t do it.”
Suspicion settles on workers at Kesse’s condo complex
Any evidence found on or in Kesse’s Malibu doesn’t, as things stand, appear to have paved the way for investigators to make any significant breakthroughs. This is in spite of the fact that, in recent years, her family has said that the car was left bearing signs of a violent struggle and that, despite investigators’ previous claims otherwise, OPD files show DNA evidence was collected from the car.
Inevitably, Allen quickly came under police suspicion in the wake of Kesse’s disappearance. However, not least because he lived around three hours away from her home in Orlando, he was soon ruled out.
Scrutiny has also fallen on laborers who were carrying out construction and maintenance work at the Mosaic at Millenia complex in early 2006. Drew told 48 Hours that the workers, some of whom were reportedly living inside vacant condos at the Mosaic at Millenia, made his daughter feel uncomfortable: “She just said, ‘There’s a lot of workers here and they tend to just stop when I’m walking by or going to my car, and they just look.’”
However, although an anonymous phone tip led Wright to interview a maintenance worker, no suspect has ever been arrested or charged in connection with Kesse’s disappearance. In the years that have passed, her family has remained without answers as to how she could simply up and vanish.
“Not even a direction 19 years later”
In 2018, the frustrated Kesses sought to take the investigation into their own hands, suing the city of Orlando and the OPD for access to her case files. The following year, the parties reached a settlement whereby the city and the OPD agreed to hand over the files. Per CBS, Orlando police - which would no longer lead the investigation into Jennifer’s disappearance - gave the Kesses more than 16,000 pages of documents, as well as 67 hours of video tapes.
Armed with the case files, the Kesses hired a team of PIs to continue the search. “It gives us great hope,” Drew said at the time, according to FOX35 Orlando. “We’re only looking for that needle in a haystack, and that one call, that one piece of information.” In late 2022, the case was also taken up for review by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE), Florida’s state police agency.
But in an update posted this week on a GoFundMe page set up by the Kesses, Drew spoke of the family’s exasperation that, nearly two decades on from the day she vanished, Jennifer’s disappearance continues to baffle. “How can a missing person’s case with such awareness not produce even a direction 19 years later is inconceivable,” he wrote. “Yet [it is] very true and we, Jennifer’s family and friends, live with that very real fact day in and day out.”
The Kesses say they will never stop searching for Jennifer - “how can you, as a parent, step aside”, Joyce told WFTV Channel 9. But they must also contemplate the crushing possibility that they might remain forever in the dark about out what happened to her. “I don’t know how to reconcile in my own head that we may never have an answer,” Joyce laments.
Get your game on! Whether you’re into NFL touchdowns, NBA buzzer-beaters, world-class soccer goals, or MLB home runs, our app has it all. Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more – plus, stay updated on the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.