2024 MLB Draft analysis: Winners and losers

It is virtually impossible to talk about real winners and losers in the MLB Draft until months or even years after the event. The Pirates have clearly been on a winner with last year’s first pick in Paul Skenes, but often a player will need to develop in the minors for years before it becomes clear if they were a star or a dud. For every Daryl Strawberry, there is also a Billy Beane.

But there are a few takeaways that we can surmise from this year’s event already, so let’s get into it.

The Rocky Mountain Highs

The Colorado Rockies, often on the receiving end of the baseball gods’ tough love, got a helping hand this year. They snagged Charlie Condon, who many thought was the top player in the draft, at the third pick. Picture this: a guy with light-tower power launching balls out of Coors Field. The Rockies also added Brody Brecht, a pitcher with raw stuff reminiscent of Paul Skenes, at No. 38. Sure, he needs to work on his control, but his fastball-slider combo could turn into a deadly duo in Denver. And if that wasn’t enough, outfielder Jared Thomas brings a power-speed mix that could really shine in the Mile High City.

Milwaukee Misfires

Now, let’s talk about the Brewers, an organization known for turning draftees into stars. But this year’s selections left some scratching their heads. Braylon Payne at No. 17 was a bit of a surprise – he’s speedy with some bat potential, but it felt early. Tennessee’s Blake Burke, a power-only first baseman with defensive issues, also raised eyebrows. The high-school hurlers, Bryce Meccage and Chris Levonas, have upside but need a lot of polishing. It’s not that the Brewers can’t turn this into a goldmine, but it’s a draft that left some wondering what might have been.

Nationals Knock It Out

For the second year running, the Nationals find themselves in the winner’s circle. They kicked things off with Seaver King, a versatile leadoff hitter who can play just about anywhere. They also grabbed Caleb Lomavita, perhaps the best offensive catcher in the draft, with potential to play multiple positions. Then there’s Luke Dickerson, a prep riser with five-tool potential. It’s a balanced class with both high floors and high ceilings – a strong showing from the Nats.

Dakota Jordan’s Dilemma

Dakota Jordan’s slide out of the first day was the shocker of the draft. With a power-speed combo that rivals the best, his hit tool concerns apparently scared teams off. Maybe he’s a tough sign heading back to Mississippi State, which would make the Bulldogs winners here. Or maybe a team is just waiting for the right moment to snag him. Either way, Jordan’s name looms large over Day 2.

Honeycutt Heads to Baltimore

Vance Honeycutt knows his game needs work – strikeouts being the big issue. But landing with the Orioles, who have a knack for developing hitters, could be just what the doctor ordered. His plus power, elite speed, and Gold Glove defense make him a tantalizing prospect. If anyone can unlock his potential, it’s the O’s.

Trey Yesavage’s Slide

Trey Yesavage was once talked about as a top-10 pick, but he found himself waiting until No. 20, where the Blue Jays finally picked him up. With three above-average pitches and excellent command, his fall was surprising. Whether it was due to health concerns or other factors, Toronto might have landed a steal if Yesavage gets a strong signing bonus and delivers on his potential.

Wake Forest’s Winning Trio

Despite a disappointing end to their season, the Wake Forest Demon Deacons saw three players go in the top 10: Chase Burns, Nick Kurtz, and Seaver King. This feat made them only the second school to achieve such a draft milestone since Rice in 2004. It’s a testament to their talent and a silver lining for a team that fell short of its championship aspirations.

Oakland Fans’ Future Woes

The A’s drafted well, picking up Nick Kurtz, Tommy White, and Gage Jump. But here’s the rub: Oakland fans won’t likely see these talents play at the Coliseum. With the team moving to Sacramento and then Las Vegas, it’s a bitter pill for the loyal fans who have stuck with the A’s through thick and thin.

Guardians and Bazzana’s Big Moment

With the first No. 1 pick in franchise history, the Guardians selected Travis Bazzana, a power-hitting infielder from Oregon State. A couple of historic firsts, with Cleveland’s first ever first pick, they took the first ever Australian at first pick. And what a player Bazzana is. He brings needed pop to Cleveland’s lineup and looks set to make an impact sooner rather than later. Bazzana’s selection signals a bright future for the Guardians, aiming to develop him into a cornerstone player.

Fans of Homers, Rejoice

Charlie Condon, the draft’s top power hitter, heading to the Rockies is a dream for homer fans. Condon’s 37 home runs at Georgia set a BBCOR-era record, and his potential to light up Coors Field is sky-high. We might see him mashing taters in the big leagues by the end of next season.

Braves’ Big Pick

Two standout value picks were Trey Yesavage to the Blue Jays at No. 20 and Cam Caminiti to the Braves at No. 24. Caminiti, the best high school pitcher in the draft, offers a Max Fried starter kit, and the Braves are ready to work their developmental magic again.

The Two-Way Sensation

This draft was a win for fans of unique talents. Florida’s Jac Caglianone, the No. 6 pick, will begin his career as a two-way player. Jurrangelo Cijntje, taken by the Mariners, will continue to pitch with both arms. It’s a great time for those who love seeing versatility and pure athleticism on display.

The Agonizing Pace

Lastly, a bit of a gripe – the draft’s pace can be excruciating. Five minutes between picks, often more with commercials, makes for a long night. As much as we love the spectacle, a quicker pace would keep the excitement rolling.

So, there you have it, folks. The winners, the losers, and everything in between from the first day of the 2024 MLB Draft. It’s a long road ahead for these young talents, but the journey is what makes baseball the beautiful game we love.