The Athletics put ‘Moneyball’ to bed with record Soderstrom deal
Tyler Soderstrom’s has penned a $86 million extension seven year extension with the MLB team.
Christmas 2025 brought a surprise to The Athletics’ temporary offices in Sacramento, and the deal pretty much laid rest the team’s ‘Moneyball’ tradition of being cautious and bringing in new talent with statistics paving the way.
The announcement of Tyler Soderstrom’s seven-year, $86 million extension, with a potential ceiling of $131 million, isn’t just a payroll move. It’s the death certificate of one era and the christening of another. For the first time in decades, the franchise has decided that young talent isn’t a commodity to be traded, but an asset to be protected with cash.
Soderstrom, at 24, is the driving force behind this transformation. His 2025 season wasn’t a fluke, but a statistical confirmation: a .276 batting average, 25 home runs, and 93 RBIs. But his true value to John Fisher and David Forst lies in his quiet versatility, the kind that took him from a projected catcher to a Gold Glove finalist in left field. In the age of advanced metrics, an impact bat who also plays above-average defense according to Statcast is a rare anomaly.
The cost of ceasing to be invisible
For years, the Athletics operated under the premise of financial invisibility. They were the team that found diamonds in the mud, only to sell them before they shone too brightly. Today, geography dictates a different strategy. The move to Las Vegas, projected for 2028, has forced a genetic mutation in the club’s management.
In the “Entertainment Capital of the World,” they’re not just competing against the Rangers or the Astros; they’re competing against a pop star’s residency at Caesars Palace or the bright lights of the Sphere.
To survive in the Nevada ecosystem, the Athletics need faces, not just numbers on an advanced stat sheet. The investment in Soderstrom adds to the $65.5 million given to Lawrence Butler and the $60 million to Brent Rooker.
The mandate of the Labor Agreement
Beyond the romanticized view of the sport, there’s a pragmatic pressure. The MLB Collective Bargaining Agreement requires teams that receive revenue sharing, a figure that for the A’s is around $70 million, to invest at least 150% of that amount in team improvement. With a payroll projected to reach $106 million by 2026, according to Spotrac estimates, the organization is obligated to spend. The signing of Luis Severino for $67 million and the recent acquisition of Jeff McNeil are pieces of a puzzle that seeks to erase the image of a 50-win team and present an organization with 76 wins and rising.
The Athletics are in limbo, playing in a minor league stadium with a capacity of 14,000, but with a deep market purse. It’s a strange, almost surreal transition, where gate receipts are the lowest in the league while contract guarantees reach record highs for the franchise.
The bet on Soderstrom is, in essence, a bet on relevance. The team that used to live by ingenuity and scarcity has understood that in the Nevada desert, the only way to survive is by investing big.
Get your game on! Whether you’re into NFL touchdowns, NBA buzzer-beaters, world-class soccer goals, or MLB home runs, our app has it all.
Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more – plus, stay updated on the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.