The rise and fall of the NBA All‑Star Game: How a once‑iconic showcase lost its edge
A journey through the history of this event that explains why a match that once sparked global interest has become virtually impossible to watch.
When Mike Malone joked after the 2023 NBA All‑Star Game that it was “the worst basketball game ever played,” he wasn’t just being dramatic. He was putting words to a decline that fans have felt for years.
Back in 1993, 20 million Americans tuned in to watch the league’s brightest stars battle in Salt Lake City. Michael Jordan dropped 30 points, the game went to overtime, and hometown heroes John Stockton and Karl Malone shared MVP honors. The All‑Star Game wasn’t just entertainment—it was a clash of pride, legacy, and rivalry. It mattered.
Fast‑forward three decades, and the 2023 edition drew just 4.6 million viewers, the lowest in the event’s 72‑year history. Jaylen Brown summed it up bluntly: “That wasn’t basketball. It was a glorified warm‑up.”
So what happened to the NBA’s crown‑jewel exhibition?
From fierce competition to friendly exhibition
The All‑Star Game debuted in 1951, and over the decades the NBA kept adding elements to make the weekend special. Jerry West hit a game‑winner in 1972. The three‑point contest arrived in 1976, the dunk contest became a staple in 1984, and by the ’90s the entire weekend was the most anticipated spectacle of the regular season.
Fans loved seeing the world’s best players go at each other—really go at each other.
In 2003, Jordan hit what looked like a game‑winner over Shawn Marion, only for Kobe Bryant to draw a foul on the final possession. Kobe sank two of three free throws, and after double overtime, the student beat the master.
In 2012, a veteran Kobe—nose freshly broken by Dwyane Wade—switched into predator mode, guarding LeBron James in crunch time. LeBron passed up two potential game‑winning shots, prompting Kobe to bark at him: “Shoot the f—ing ball.”
That was the All‑Star Game: competitive, emotional, personal.
A new era with no villains—and fewer stakes
Today’s NBA is different. Superstars are friends. Rivalries are softer. Social media encourages players to avoid conflict. And the league’s business model—built around protecting its stars—has unintentionally drained the competitive fire.
The result? A game that feels more like a midseason vacation than a battle of the best.
Scoring exploded. Defense vanished. In 2016, the West put up a record 196 points. In 2017, fans witnessed 83 dunks and a combined 374 points—numbers that felt more like a video game than a showcase of elite basketball.
Some blamed the “Curry effect,” arguing that the rise of the three‑pointer turned the game into a shooting exhibition. But the truth is deeper.
The NBA tried to fix it—briefly, it worked
In 2018, the league scrapped East vs. West and introduced a captain’s draft. It generated headlines, but not competitiveness.
By 2019, after 167 attempted threes, the NBA had seen enough.
Then came 2020—and the Elam Ending. In honor of Kobe Bryant, the final quarter was played to a target score, and the result was electric. Players defended. Fouls increased. Pride was on the line. Giannis blocked LeBron twice. Kyle Lowry took charges. Kawhi made clutch steals.
It felt like a playoff game. LeBron said afterward, “You could feel Kobe’s presence out there.”
But the magic didn’t last.
2024 and 2025: rock bottom
After Malone blasted the 2023 game, the NBA ditched both the Elam Ending and the captain’s draft, returning to East vs. West in 2024. Adam Silver promised defense. Instead, fans got an even bigger disaster.
Then came 2025—the low point. Instead of two teams, the NBA created four. Three were made up of eight All‑Stars each, and the fourth featured rising young players. The event consisted of mini‑games, semifinals, and a final. It was confusing, chaotic, and widely mocked.
Draymond Green, working as a commentator, was asked to rate the format from 1 to 10. His answer:“Ten being the best? Zero. It sucks.”
The entire event lasted three hours. Actual basketball? 42 minutes—less than a quarter of the broadcast.
The real issue: money, risk, and the modern NBA economy
The All‑Star Game’s decline mirrors problems in MLB and the NFL: falling ratings, rising apathy, and a struggle to find a format that works.
But the NBA’s core issue is financial.
Television deals have exploded. Player salaries have skyrocketed. And with that comes unprecedented risk. A star getting hurt in an exhibition game could lose tens of millions.
In the ’90s, earning $10 million a year was rare. Today, it’s the average salary for a role player.
The shift in All‑Star competitiveness since 2016 aligns not with Steph Curry’s rise, but with the NBA’s massive TV deal with ESPN—$24 billion over nine years, triple the previous contract.
This season, the league signed a new deal worth $76 billion over the next decade.
The All‑Star Game is no longer an opportunity. It’s a liability.
Even the dunk contest isn’t safe
The decline extends beyond Sunday night.
The slam dunk contest—once the stage for Jordan vs. Dominique, Vince Carter, and Jason Richardson—has lost its star power. Today, G League standout Mac McClung gets a two‑way contract each year just to compete, then returns to the minors.
Shai Gilgeous‑Alexander argues the problem is simple:“Money talks. If there were more incentives, players would take it more seriously.”
He’s not wrong. The NBA Cup proved that half‑million‑dollar bonuses can ignite real competition.
Victor Wembanyama, meanwhile, wants to revive the spirit himself: “I want to push the stars to play hard. And if they don’t, I’ll do it alone. I want to be the guy diving for loose balls and fighting every possession.”
It’s a noble sentiment. But one player can’t fix a structural problem.
The truth: the All‑Star Game simply isn’t what it used to be
There are plenty of theories about how to fix the All‑Star Game. More money. New formats. A return to tradition. A complete overhaul.
But the reality is simple:The NBA All‑Star Game has drifted far from what once made it special.
What should be the pinnacle of competitive basketball has become a yearly disappointment—an event searching for an identity in a league that has changed faster than the game itself.
Get your game on! Whether you’re into NFL touchdowns, NBA buzzer-beaters, world-class soccer goals, or MLB home runs, our app has it all.
Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more – plus, stay updated on the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.