The Divisional Round trap: when home field isn’t enough
As we enter the Divisional Round of the NFL Playoffs this weekend, we’ll find out just how much experience matters versus home-field “advantage”.
Home-field advantage is supposed to be the great equalizer in the NFL playoffs. The crowd is louder. The routines are familiar. The weather favors the home team. For young quarterbacks, it’s often the difference between settling in and spiraling early.
And yet, year after year, the Divisional Round keeps delivering the same cruel lesson. Home field can help you start, but it doesn’t guarantee you’ll finish. That’s the trap facing the NFL this weekend, as the 2025–26 postseason sends four younger quarterbacks into Divisional Round games at home against opponents led by far more seasoned passers.
Why the Divisional Round is different
By this stage of the playoffs, every opponent is elite. Every defense adjusts. Every mistake is magnified. And while home-field advantage can calm nerves early in the game, it doesn’t eliminate the most difficult part of postseason football - winning in clutch moments. That’s where experience comes in and starts to matter.
This weekend’s quarterback divide
Every Divisional matchup this weekend features a version of the same contrast- a confident home quarterback with just one playoff start under their belt, facing an opponent who has already lived through postseason chaos.
- Bills @ Broncos
- Josh Allen - 8th NFL season, 13 playoff starts
- Bo Nix - 2nd NFL season, 1 playoff start
Broncos quarterback Bo Nix is playing his second full NFL season at home, backed by a crowd desperate to believe. Across from him stands Bills QB Josh Allen, now deep into his prime and fully comfortable in hostile environments and high-pressure finishes.
- 49ers @ Seahawks
- Brock Purdy - 4th NFL season, 5 playoff starts
- Sam Darnold - 8th season, 1 playoff start
Niners QB Brock Purdy has grown into a playoff-tested quarterback, but Seattle QB Sam Darnold brings nearly a decade of NFL experience into a game that’s likely to hinge on situational decisions rather than raw talent.
- Texans @ Patriots
- C.J. Stroud - 3rd season, 5 playoff starts
- Drake Maye - 2nd season, 1 playoff start
Pats QB Drake Maye benefits from home field, but Texans QB C.J. Stroud has already learned what it takes to win playoff games where patience matters more than fireworks.
- Rams @ Bears
- Matthew Stafford - 17th season, 11 playoff starts plus a Super Bowl victory
- Caleb Williams - 2nd season, 1 playoff start
Bears QB Caleb Williams gets the crowd, the weather, and the energy, but Rams veteran QB Matthew Stafford has been navigating games like this for 17 seasons, including a Super Bowl run built on surviving moments exactly like these.
While playing at home does come with advantages, Divisional Round home teams are just slightly above .500 since 2020. Experience matters too. So while none of this guarantees either an upset or a veteran sweep (young quarterbacks win playoff games every year), the Divisional Round has a way of exposing what hasn’t been tested yet.
Related stories
Get your game on! Whether you’re into NFL touchdowns, NBA buzzer-beaters, world-class soccer goals, or MLB home runs, our app has it all.
Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more – plus, stay updated on the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.