Who were the best QBs at the 2024 NFL Combine? Milton, McCarthy, and Penix Jr.

The three most promising quarterback prospects for the 2024 season, Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, and Drake Maye, opted not to throw at the recent NFL Combine. This decision allowed other quarterbacks in the class to showcase their skills and catch the attention of scouts, potentially securing a place in the upcoming Draft. The 2024 NFL Combine was a showcase dominated by quarterbacks who impressed spectators with their outstanding talent and athleticism.

Joe Milton

Joe Milton was the standout player of the day, with his powerful arm, which allowed him to throw the ball nearly 80 yards downfield. Despite occasional issues with accuracy, his ability to make precise passes and raw strength were undeniable highlights. Although some missed throws, his sheer arm strength left onlookers in admiration, reminiscent of a playground maestro sinking three-pointers with ease.

However, he received criticism for his one-dimensional playing style, with Tennessee relying solely on one-read passes while having him as the first QB. It’s possible he could switch to a tight-end position, but it’s likely that the team that chooses him in the Draft will try to monetize his arm strength before considering such a move.

J.J. McCarthy, Michigan

Milton was undoubtedly gifted, but JJ McCarthy and Michael Penix Jr. also demonstrated excellent precision and timing.

McCarthy’s charismatic leadership and seamless execution were impressive, as he orchestrated plays with finesse and enthusiasm. Although Michigan’s J.J. McCarthy did not participate in the Senior Bowl and Shrine Bowl festivities, his draft stock may have risen slightly by staying idle. However, reports of him dealing with hamstring tightness have cast some doubt on his expectations heading into the NFL Combine.

McCarthy is a prospect that divides many draft enthusiasts. On the one hand, he has a strong track record of playing winning football at a big program, and his flashes of top-shelf talent have many believing he could be a first-round pick.

Michael Penix Jr., Washington

Penix Jr. displayed his remarkable mastery of the quarterback craft, showing off his smooth stroke and quick release during the game. His impressive performance reaffirmed his first-round talent status and left a lasting impression on scouts and coaches.

However, despite his undeniable talent, there are lingering concerns about his injury history, particularly his issues with ACL injuries. This has led to questions about his long-term durability and potential risk for future injuries. Some teams may hesitate to draft him due to these concerns, while others may consider his talent worth the risk.

Despite the uncertainty surrounding his draft placement, some potential suitors are considering him for the coveted fifth-year option, giving them an extra year to evaluate his potential. This has made his draft stock a subject of intrigue, with teams weighing the risk against the undeniable upside. Ultimately, each team will have to decide based on their own evaluation of his talent, injury history, and long-term goals.