New Mexico United
- Goalkeeper
- 56 Raiko Arozarena
- Defender
- 2 Niko Hamalainen
- 3 Christopher Gloster
- 16 Will Seymore (70')
- 48 Grady Gilchrist (45')
- Midfielder
- 15 Ousman Jabang
- 21 Valentin Noël
- 17 Jake LaCava
- 5 Dayonn Harris (45')
- Forward
- 9 Justin Rennicks (62')
- 10 Greg Hurst (62')
- Substitutes
- ent Dennis Sanchez 4-4-2
- 23 Arturo Astorga
- 8 Marlon Vargas (62')
- 13 Kristopher Shakes
- 11 Cristian Nava (70')
- 7 Niall Reid-Stephen (45')
- 29 Luther Archimède (62')
- 27 Maliek Howell (45')
El Paso Locomotive
- Goalkeeper
- 99 Abraham Romero
- Defender
- 93 Tony Alfaro
- 15 Noah Dollenmayer (29')
- 25 Arturo Ortiz (45')
- Midfielder
- 5 Daniel Gomez
- 30 Robert Coronado (69')
- 12 Ricky Ruiz
- 18 Álvaro Quezada
- Forward
- 14 Rubio Rubín (69')
- 28 Omar Mora
- 19 Alex Mendez (73')
- Substitutes
- ent Junior Gonzalez 3-4-3
- 1 Sebastian Mora-Mora
- 13 Roberto Avila
- 29 Kenneth Hoban (45')
- 6 Eric Calvillo (69')
- 16 Gabi Torres (73')
- 21 Kofi Twumasi (29')
- 9 Diego Abitia (69')