San José Earthquakes
- 36 Earl Ewwards
- 28 Benji Kikanovic
- 2 Jamar Ricketts
- 34 Beau Leroux
- 5 Daniel Munie
- 18 Reid Roberts
- 7 Ousseni Bouda
- 14 Ronaldo Vieira
- 19 Preston Judd
- 20 Nick Fernandez
- 16 Jack Skahan
- Substitutes
- entBruce Arena4-2-3-1
- 31 Francesco Montali
- 6 Ian Harkes
- 3 Paul Marie
- 40 Jonathan Gonzalez
- 17 Jack Jasinski
- 25 Max Floriani
- 32 Nonso Adimabua
- 79 Darius Johnson
- 4 David Romney
Orlando City
- 71 Maxime Crépeau
- 24 Griffin Dorsey
- 77 Iván Angulo
- 3 Adrián Marín
- 6 Robin Jansson
- 4 David Brekalo
- 8 Braian Ojeda
- 20 Eduard Atuesta
- 10 Martín Ojeda
- 22 Justin Ellis
- 11 Tiago
- Substitutes
- ent3-4-2-1
- 14 Tyrese Spicer
- 29 Tahir Reid-Brown
- 16 Wilder Cartagena
- 87 Marco Pasalic
- 12 Javier Otero
- 19 Zakaria Taifi
- 57 Iago Teodoro
- 5 Luis Otávio