New York Red Bulls
- 34 Ethan Horvath
- 3 Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty
- 56 Matthew Dos Santos
- 4 Gustav Berggren
- 2 Justin Che
- 12 Dylan Nealis
- 48 Ronald Donkor
- 10 Forsberg
- 16 Julian Hall
- 7 Cade Cowell
- 70 Andy Rojas
- Substitutes
- entMichael Bradley4-3-3
- 6 Robert Voloder
- 77 John McCarthy
- 80 Nate Worth
- 37 Mohammed Sofo
- 91 Mijahir Jiménez
- 39 Nehuén Benedetti
- 26 Tim Parker
- 14 Julián Bazán
- 20 Juan Mina
Orlando City
- 71 Maxime Crépeau
- 24 Griffin Dorsey
- 44 Bernardo Rhein
- 8 Braian Ojeda
- 57 Iago Teodoro
- 6 Robin Jansson
- 77 Iván Angulo
- 5 Luis Otávio
- 23 Harvey Sarajian
- 7 Griezmann
- 11 Tiago
- Substitutes
- ent4-4-1-1
- 14 Tyrese Spicer
- 29 Tahir Reid-Brown
- 16 Wilder Cartagena
- 3 Adrián Marín
- 12 Javier Otero
- 19 Zakaria Taifi
- 65 Gustavo Caraballo