Ahead of Real Madrid’s Bayern matchup, there are dilemmas for Arbeloa

Defeat is the mother of doubt. And doubt has been a constant companion for Real Madrid this season. Doubts about how the team will respond to the latest setback. Doubts about how Álvaro Arbeloa will reassemble his lineup after this absence or that return. The same anxieties that always hover on the eve of facing Bayern Munich. But this is the Champions League — Real Madrid’s competition. And it’s also the European Clásico, the most frequently played matchup in seven decades of continental soccer rivalry. A duel from which Madrid has grown accustomed to emerging unscathed. A precedent that keeps alive the hope, the belief, in a season that increasingly feels like a single‑card gamble. Everything on the Champions League.

Madrid boss must decide on returning Real stars

Arbeloa must shuffle his cards now. Madrid’s recent run of five straight wins, including the derby and both legs against Manchester City, came with a settled starting XI. He found that lineup in Vigo and carried it through the derby with only minimal tweaks, most of them forced by circumstance. A run of games in which he was missing both Kylian Mbappé and Jude Bellingham - two major absences that, oddly enough, helped him complete the puzzle.

Mbappé fits. He has to fit. The Vinícius Júnior‑Brahim Díaz pairing worked well in his absence - the former providing the firepower (four goals) and the latter, the tireless craft. But that duo now gives way. Mbappé will line up alongside Vinícius up front. That part is not up for debate.

What is debatable is Bellingham: whether the Englishman is ready to start… and at whose expense. Arbeloa himself keeps that question open. “He’s been out for many weeks,” the head coach said after Saturday’s defeat to Mallorca. “He played 20 minutes against Atlético. Today it was a little over half an hour. The idea is to let him keep gaining match rhythm. He can’t be at his best without playing regularly. We need patience.”

And once Bellingham is ready, the next question is who makes way. Madrid’s midfield clicked during Los Blancos’ recent winning streak, with Fede Valverde, Thiago Pitarch, Aurélien Tchouameni and Arda Güler (and only occasional cameos from Eduardo Camavinga). Each of those four has made a strong case to keep his spot. It’s a real selection poser for Arbeloa - if not for the first leg against Bayern, then certainly for the matches to come.

If Bellingham needs to be eased in after six weeks out, even more caution is required with Éder Militão’s return after four months on the sidelines. Yet the Brazilian center back reappeared at the weekend - 118 days later - in imperious form. He played for half an hour against Mallorca and scored the equalizer with a towering header that sparked comeback dreams. Still, after so long inactive, it feels overly ambitious to imagine him starting against Bayern. And even though Antonio Rüdiger and Dean Huijsen have formed a solid partnership in recent weeks, the question with Militão is now when, not if.

That leads to another dilemma for Arbeloa: with Rüdiger back to full strength, the likely casualty seems to be Huijsen - even though the Militão‑Huijsen pairing, despite not playing together since Anfield, has been Madrid’s most-used center‑back duo this season, with 10 starts. By contrast, Militão and Rüdiger have started together only twice: against Girona and Athletic.

Meanwhile, the most fluid positions in recent matches have been the fullback spots. On the right, Arbeloa has rotated between Trent Alexander-Arnold and Dani Carvajal. Alexander-Arnold started in Mallorca and in the ties against City. Carvajal got the nod for the derby. On the left, all three options have taken turns: Ferland Mendy, Fran García, and Álvaro Carreras.

Madrid tame the Bayern beast

And in the middle of that maze of lineup questions stands Bayern. Once a monster, lately a tamed beast. The Bavarian side has its domestic work essentially done - which means pocketing yet another Bundesliga title. Their only doubt is when the almost-inevitable will be confirmed as spring arrives in Germany. They hold a nine‑point lead over Borussia Dortmund with six games to go - and they’re scoring in bunches: 100 goals in 28 league matches. Nearly four per game.

This is the most-played matchup in European Cup history - the Clásico of the Old Continent. Twenty‑eight meetings that have never decided a trophy directly but have often paved the road to one. Just like the semifinals two years ago, on Joselu’s magical night. Madrid has won seven of the last nine encounters. The last four knockout ties between them ultimately lit the path to a Champions League trophy triumph for Los Blancos (in 2013/14, 2016/17, 2017/18 and 2023/24).

Get closer to the game! Whether you like your soccer of the European variety or that on this side of the pond, our AS USA app has it all. Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more. Plus, stay updated on NFL, NBA and all other big sports stories as well as the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.

And there’s more: check out our TikTok and Instagram reels for bite-sized visual takes on all the biggest soccer news and insights.