Jason Fichtner, ex-SSA executive, warns of claiming Social Security at 62: “Claiming before 70 is a penalty”

Given you’ve landed on this article, it’s likely that you’ve come across one, or more, of the growing number of social media creators telling Americans to claim Social Security as early as possible. Some of them argue that retirees can collect more money overall by starting at 62 instead of waiting.

Well, former Social Security Administration executive Jason Fichtner wants to give you another side to that, saying that this logic leaves out the most important part of the decision.

When should I start claiming SSA?

In Senate testimony this year, and in media interviews thereafter, Fichtner criticized the popular “break-even” argument that compares total lifetime payouts at different claiming ages. While the math may show some retirees collecting more cumulative benefits by starting early, he makes the case that Social Security was designed first as protection against outliving savings.

“I continue to think a break-even analysis is the wrong framing,” said Fichtner, who previously served as acting deputy commissioner and chief economist at the SSA.

His position is blunt: “Claiming at any age before age 70 is a penalty.”

Effectively what he says is that while Americans can indeed begin retirement benefits at 62, monthly checks are permanently reduced for early claimants. Waiting until full retirement age, usually 66 or 67 depending on birth year, unlocks 100% of earned benefits. Delaying until 70 increases payments even more through delayed retirement credits.

How much more do I get for delaying SSA claim?

Fichtner noted that someone claiming at 70 instead of 62 can receive a monthly benefit about 77% higher. That’s a lot.

He also argues the government’s terminology contributes to confusion. In his testimony, Fichtner backed legislation that would rename age 62 as the “minimum monthly benefit age” and age 70 as the “maximum monthly benefit age.”

Many experts agree that claiming decisions should also account for taxes, health, work plans and survivor benefits for spouses, not just total dollars collected over time.

Why do those influencers push early SS claims?

Influencers often push early claims because the strategy looks attractive in those simple “break-even” calculations. Starting at 62 means collecting checks for more years, which can produce higher lifetime payouts for people who die younger or invest the money successfully. The message also taps into widespread fears about Social Security’s future and appeals to retirees who need income immediately.

But, as I’ve hopefully explained, this oversimplifies the decision by ignoring longevity risk, inflation protection and survivor benefits. Waiting until 70 permanently boosts monthly payments, creating a larger guaranteed income stream later in life when healthcare costs and financial pressures often increase.

As always, get professional advice when you need it.

Get closer to the game! Whether you like your soccer of the European variety or that on this side of the pond, our AS USA app has it all. Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more. Plus, stay updated on NFL, NBA and all other big sports stories as well as the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.

And there’s more: check out our TikTok and Instagram reels for bite-sized visual takes on all the biggest soccer news and insights.