| Pos. | Player | Team | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Darwin Ceren
Midfielder
|
El Salvador
|
100Percentage of penalties that ended in goals |
Hoilett
Forward
|
Canada
|
100 | |
Orbelín Pineda
Midfielder
|
Mexico
|
100 | |
Alexander López
Midfielder
|
Honduras
|
100 | |
Jonathan David
Forward
|
Canada
|
100 | |
Cyle Larin
Forward
|
Canada
|
100 | |
Raúl Jiménez
Forward
|
Mexico
|
100 | |
Christian Pulisic
Forward
|
USA
|
100 | |
Alphonso Davies
Forward
|
Canada
|
100 | |
Leon Bailey
Forward
|
Jamaica
|
100 | |
Michail Antonio
Forward
|
Jamaica
|
100 | |
Ángel Tejeda
Forward
|
Honduras
|
100 | |
| 2 |
Celso Borges
Midfielder
|
Costa Rica
|
50 |
| 3 |
Yoel Barcenas
Midfielder
|
Panama
|
0 |
Mark-Anthony Kaye
Midfielder
|
Canada
|
0 | |
Eric Davis
Defender
|
Panama
|
0 | |
Nelson Bonilla
Forward
|
El Salvador
|
0 |
