| Pos. | Player | Team | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Brian Rodríguez
Midfielder
|
América
|
100Percentage of penalties that ended in goals |
Julián Quiñones
Forward
|
América
|
100 | |
Everardo Rubio
Defender
|
Herediano
|
100 | |
Griffin Dorsey
Midfielder
|
Houston Dynamo FC
|
100 | |
|
Tomás Chancalay
Forward
|
New England Revolution
|
100 | |
Martín Ojeda
Midfielder
|
Orlando City SC
|
100 | |
Facundo Torres
Midfielder
|
Orlando City SC
|
100 | |
|
Byron Bonilla
Forward
|
Real Estelí
|
100 | |
|
Luis Paradela
Forward
|
Saprissa
|
100 | |
Gignac
Forward
|
Tigres
|
100 | |
Rondón
Forward
|
Pachuca
|
100 | |
| 2 |
Christian Ramirez
Forward
|
Columbus Crew
|
0 |
|
Arquímides Ordóñez
Forward
|
FC Cincinnati
|
0 | |
|
Forster Ajago
Forward
|
Nashville SC
|
0 |
