Chicago Fire
- Goalkeeper
- 1 Christopher Brady
- Defender
- 27 Dylan Borso 76'
- 16 Joel Waterman
- 14 Viktor Radojevic 84'
- 4 Mbekezeli Mbokazi 84'
- Midfielder
- 6 Anton Salétros 64'
- 22 Mauricio Pineda
- 35 Sergio Oregel Jr.
- Forward
- 9 Hugo Cuypers 63'
- 7 Maren Haile-Selassie
- 11 Philip Zinckernagel
- Substitutes
- ent Gregg Berhalter 4-3-3
- 44 Josh Cohen
- 15 Andrew Gutman (76')
- 29 Dawid Poreba (84')
- 42 Djé D'Avilla
- 20 Jason Shokalook (63')
- 3 Jack Elliott (84')
- 17 Robin Lod (64')
St. Louis City SC
- Goalkeeper
- 1 Bürki
- Defender
- 32 Baumgartl
- 5 Lukas MacNaughton
- 21 Dante Polvara
- Midfielder
- 8 Chris Durkin
- 6 Conrad Wallem 58'
- 24 Daniel Edelman
- 14 Tomas Totland 84'
- Forward
- 36 Cedric Teuchert 58'
- 17 Marcel Hartel
- 16 Sergio Córdova 84'
- Substitutes
- ent Yoann Damet 3-4-2-1
- 10 Eduard Löwen (58')
- 59 Mykhi Joyner (58')
- 27 Fallou Fall
- 4 Mamadou Fall (84')
- 39 Benjamin Lundt
- 11 Simon Becher (84')
- 28 Miguel Perez