América
- Goalkeeper
- 30 Rodolfo Cota
- Defender
- 26 Cristian Borja 73'
- 4 Sebastián Cáceres
- 5 Kevin Álvarez
- 3 Israel Reyes
- Midfielder
- 28 Erick Sanchez 76'
- 13 Alan Cervantes
- 23 Raphael Veiga
- 7 Brian Rodríguez 79'
- 12 Isaías Violante 73'
- Forward
- 9 Henry Martin 76'
- Substitutes
- entGuillermo Almada4-2-3-1
- 27 Ícaro (76')
- 186 Diego Arriaga (73')
- 33 Patricio Salas
- 189 Alejandro Cárdenas (76')
- 22 Óscar Perea (79')
- 34 Dagoberto Espinoza (73')
- 21 Fernando Tapia
- 29 Roman Juarez del Castillo
- 2 Emilio Lara
- 6 Edwin Cerrillo
- 20 Alexis Gutiérrez
Columbus Crew
- Goalkeeper
- 28 Patrick Schulte
- Defender
- 12 Cesar Ruvalcaba
- 31 Steven Moreira 69'
- 25 Sean Zawadzki
- 18 Malte Amundsen
- Midfielder
- 11 Brook Lennon
- 16 Taha Habroune 87'
- 50 Tarun Karumanchi
- 7 Dylan Chambost 65'
- Forward
- 10 Brais 65'
- Josef Martínez 65'
- Substitutes
- entLaurent Courtois4-4-2
- Gonzalo Tapia (65')
- 46 Chase Adams
- 45 Owen Presthus
- 26 Lautaro Giaccone
- 23 Mohamed Farsi
- 2 Andrés Herrera (87')
- 54 Luke Pruter
- 14 Amar Sejdic
- 1 Nicholas Hagen
- Eric Bailly (69')
- 8 Daniel Gazdag (65')
- 20 André Gomes (65')