San Diego FC
- Goalkeeper
- 18 Duran Ferree
- Defender
- 5 Kieran Sargeant (45')
- 26 Manu Duah
- 97 Christopher McVey
- 27 Luca Bombino
- Midfielder
- 8 Onni Valakari (90')
- 19 David Vazquez (68')
- 20 Godoy (45')
- Forward
- 7 Marcus Ingvartsen x2
- 90 Amahl Pellegrino (77')
- 10 Anders Dreyer
- Substitutes
- ent Mikey Varas 4-3-3
- 77 Alex Mighten (68')
- 14 Bryan Zamblé
- 15 Pedro Soma (45')
- 29 Anisse Saidi (90')
- 1 CJ dos Santos
- 33 Oscar Verhoeven (45')
- 25 Ian Pilcher
- 70 Alejandro Alvarado Jr. (77')
- 9 Lewis Morgan
FC Cincinnati
- Goalkeeper
- 18 Roman Celentano
- Defender
- 21 Matt Miazga
- 4 Nick Hagglund (72')
- 12 Miles Robinson (45')
- Midfielder
- 20 Pavel Bucha
- 17 Kenji Mboma Dem (72')
- 11 Samuel Gidi
- 27 Brian Anunga
- Forward
- 10 Evander Ferreira
- 22 Gerardo Valenzuela (45')
- 9 Ahoueke Denkey (90')
- Substitutes
- ent Pat Noonan 3-4-2-1
- 55 Ayoub Lajhar
- 99 Ayoub Jabbari (90')
- 3 Gilberto Flores
- 13 Evan Louro
- 16 Tom Barlow x2 (45')
- 5 Obinna Nwobodo (72')
- 24 Kyle Smith (45')
- 29 Bryan Ramírez (72')
- 66 Ender Echenique