Columbus Crew
- 28 Patrick Schulte
- 2 Andrés Herrera
- 18 Malte Amundsen
- 17 Sékou Bangoura
- 31 Steven Moreira
- 25 Sean Zawadzki
- 23 Mohamed Farsi
- 7 Dylan Chambost
- 8 Daniel Gazdag
- 16 Taha Habroune
- 27 Max Arfsten
- Substitutes
- entLaurent Courtois4-2-3-1
- Brais
- 22 Tristan Brown
- 14 Amar Sejdic
- 45 Owen Presthus
- 19 Jamal Thiaré
- 90 Nariman Akhundzada
- 1 Nicholas Hagen
- 30 Hugo Picard
- 12 Cesar Ruvalcaba
FC Cincinnati
- 18 Roman Celentano
- 20 Pavel Bucha
- 66 Ender Echenique
- 12 Miles Robinson
- 21 Matt Miazga
- 11 Samuel Gidi
- 22 Gerardo Valenzuela
- 5 Obinna Nwobodo
- 9 Ahoueke Denkey
- 17 Kenji Mboma Dem
- 10 Evander Ferreira
- Substitutes
- entPat Noonan3-4-2-1
- 88 Andrei Chirila
- 16 Tom Barlow
- 13 Evan Louro
- 14 Kristian Fletcher
- 15 Teenage Hadebe
- 55 Ayoub Lajhar
- 27 Brian Anunga
- 4 Nick Hagglund
- 99 Ayoub Jabbari