New York City
- 49 Matt Freese
- 24 Tayvon Gray
- 2 Nico Cavallo
- 32 Jonathan Shore
- 13 Thiago Martina
- 6 James Sands
- 26 Agustín Ojeda
- 7 Nicolás Fernández
- 11 Talles Magno
- 8 Andrés Perea
- 88 Malachi Jones
- Substitutes
- entPascal Jansen4-1-4-1
- 17 Hannes Wolf
- 15 Kevin Pierre
- 87 Arnau Farnós
- 29 Máximo Carrizo
- 23 Max Murray
- 30 Tomás Romero
- Bénie Traoré
- 99 Seymour Reid
- 35 Mitja Ilenic
Toronto FC
- 1 Luka Gavran
- 19 Kobe Franklin
- 20 Daniel Salloi
- 38 Jackson Gilman
- 25 Walker Zimmerman
- 12 Zane Monlouis
- 22 Richie Laryea
- 21 Jonathan Osorio
- 17 Emilio Aristizábal
- 7 Theo Corbeanu
- 11 Derrick Etienne
- Substitutes
- entRobin Fraser3-4-2-1
- 23 Yarbrough
- 78 Malik Henry
- 14 Alonso Coello
- 29 Deandre Kerr
- 99 Jules-Anthony Vilsaint
- 10 Djordje Mihailović
- 77 Adisa De Rosario
- 44 Raheem Edwards