New York City

• Goalkeeper
• 49 Matt Freese
• Defender
• 34 Raul Gustavo 76'
• 24 Tayvon Gray
• 22 Kevin O'Toole
• 13 Thiago Martina
• Midfielder
• 21 Aiden O'Neill
• 26 Agustín Ojeda 66'
• 5 Kai Trewin 85'
• 10 Maxi Moralez
• 17 Hannes Wolf
• Forward
• 7 Nicolás Fernández

• Substitutes
• ent Pascal Jansen 4-2-3-1
• 11 Talles Magno (66')
• 15 Kevin Pierre
• 32 Jonathan Shore
• 55 Keaton Parks (76')
• 29 Máximo Carrizo
• 19 Strahinja Tanasijevic
• 30 Tomás Romero
• 99 Seymour Reid (85')
• 2 Nico Cavallo

Charlotte FC

• Goalkeeper
• 1 Kristijan Kahlina
• Defender
• 3 Tim Ream 45'
• 44 Morrison Agyemang
• 15 Harry Toffolo
• 14 Nathan Byrne
• Midfielder
• 16 Biel Mas 92'
• 13 Brandt Bronico 76'
• 10 Wilfred Zaha
• 37 Rodolfo Aloko 68'
• 8 Ashley Westwood
• Forward
• 9 Idan Toklomati 76'

• Substitutes
• ent Dean Smith 4-2-3-1
• 23 David Schnegg
• 18 Kerwin Vargas (68')
• 7 Archie Goodwin (76')
• 17 De La Torre (76')
• 11 Liel Abada
• 25 Tyger Smalls
• 21 Tyler Miller
• 28 Djibril Diani (92')
• 4 Andrew Privett (45')