Thunder move one win from NBA Finals after controversial Game 5 leaves Spurs furious

The numbers had been piling up before Game 5 of the Western Conference Finals between the Thunder and Spurs.

Back in Oklahoma City, with the Knicks already waiting after their emphatic 4-0 sweep of the Cavaliers, everyone was reaching for the calculator ahead of what felt like the defining game of the series. Each team had won once at home and once on the road, leaving the matchup tied 2-2.

History said Game 5 mattered enormously.

In NBA history, teams that win Game 5 in a best-of-seven series tied 2-2 have gone on to advance 81.8% of the time, posting a combined 198-44 record. Oklahoma City’s franchise, including its Seattle SuperSonics history, entered the night 10-8 in these situations. San Antonio, one of the defining organizations of the 21st century, was 14-10.

The percentages were close. The pressure was not.

History favored whoever struck first

The Thunder also carried a dominant record when taking a 3-2 series lead. They had gone 12-2 in best-of-seven series after moving ahead 3-2, but just 3-11 after falling behind by the same margin.

In other words, Oklahoma City historically finished the job when it gained control, but rarely survived when chasing.

Their comeback wins after trailing 3-2 came against the Grizzlies in 2014, and, during the Seattle era, against the Bucks in 1980 and the Suns in 1979. Last season, they split the first four games of the NBA Finals against the Pacers before winning Game 5 and eventually claiming the title in seven games.

The Spurs had similar trends.

San Antonio owned an all-time 17-3 record when leading a series 3-2, but had only recovered from a 2-3 deficit once. That comeback came in 2008, when Tim Duncan and the Spurs beat Chris Paul’s Hornets before eventually losing to Kobe Bryant and the Lakers.

This was only the fourth Western Conference Finals since 2011 to be tied 2-2, and the first since 2018, when the Warriors rallied past James Harden’s Rockets after trailing 3-2.

But by tipoff, none of the historical trends really mattered anymore.

The Knicks could only sit back and wait while the NBA’s two best regular-season teams battled through a spectacular series that kept growing in drama and intensity.

Victor Wembanyama’s rise as the league’s newest phenomenon was colliding head-on with the legacy questions surrounding Shai Gilgeous-Alexander. Every possession felt heavy with consequence.

And then came the officiating controversy.

Spurs left furious by controversial calls

The Thunder eventually pulled away for a 127-114 victory, but much of the postgame discussion centered on the referees.

The frustration peaked during the third quarter with San Antonio trailing 98-88. The Spurs believed Oklahoma City got away with multiple crucial calls, including an uncalled goaltend, a missed kicked-ball violation by Chet Holmgren, and what appeared to be a clearly ignored challenge request from Spurs coach Mitch Johnson.

Moments later, Gilgeous-Alexander went to the free-throw line again, Johnson was hit with a technical foul, and veteran referee Tony Brothers was caught laughing with Lu Dort on the sideline during a stoppage in play.

The optics only intensified the anger surrounding a Thunder team already criticized by opponents for constantly pressuring officials and drawing fouls.

Gilgeous-Alexander finished with 32 points and nine assists while shooting 9-for-17 from the field. He also attempted 17 free throws, reigniting debate over foul-baiting and flopping across the league.

Thunder now one win away

To Oklahoma City’s credit, the defending champions again looked like the deeper and more complete team.

Five Thunder players scored at least 20 points, while Alex Caruso continued one of the most remarkable playoff supporting runs in recent memory. Caruso scored 22 points, knocked down 4 of 8 three-pointers, and is now shooting better than 47% from beyond the arc this postseason.

The Spurs got 24 points from Stephon Castle and 22 from Julian Champagnie, but Wembanyama struggled through one of his roughest games of the playoffs. The French superstar shot just 4-for-15 from the field and missed all five of his three-point attempts, though he did go a perfect 12-for-12 at the free-throw line.

San Antonio cut the deficit to 107-99, but never seriously threatened after that.

Now the Thunder head to Texas with a 3-2 series lead and a chance to punch their ticket to the NBA Finals.

And the numbers?

Well, everybody already knows what they say.

Get closer to the game! Whether you like your soccer of the European variety or that of this side of the pond, our AS USA app has it all. Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more. Plus, stay updated on NFL, NBA and all other big sports stories as well as the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.

And there’s more: check out our TikTok and Instagram reels for bite-sized visual takes on all the biggest soccer news and insights.