New York Red Bulls

• Goalkeeper
• 77 John McCarthy
• Defender
• 56 Matthew Dos Santos
• 6 Robert Voloder
• 12 Dylan Nealis
• 3 Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty 65'
• Midfielder
• 48 Ronald Donkor
• 15 Adri Mehmeti
• 10 Forsberg 65'
• Forward
• 11 Jorge Ruvalcaba 77'
• 16 Julian Hall 77'
• 7 Cade Cowell 66'

• Substitutes
• ent Michael Bradley 4-3-3
• 79 Rafael Mosquera (66')
• 34 Ethan Horvath
• 20 Juan Mina (65')
• 26 Tim Parker
• 37 Mohammed Sofo (77')
• 13 Choupo-Moting (77')
• 39 Nehuén Benedetti (65')

New York City

• Goalkeeper
• 49 Matt Freese
• Defender
• 13 Thiago Martina
• 24 Tayvon Gray
• 2 Nico Cavallo
• 34 Raul Gustavo
• Midfielder
• 26 Agustín Ojeda
• 88 Malachi Jones 45'
• 21 Aiden O'Neill
• 5 Kai Trewin
• 10 Maxi Moralez 86'
• Forward
• 7 Nicolás Fernández 91'

• Substitutes
• ent Pascal Jansen 4-2-3-1
• 8 Andrés Perea (86')
• 19 Strahinja Tanasijevic
• 55 Keaton Parks
• 87 Arnau Farnós (91')
• 11 Talles Magno (45')
• 30 Tomás Romero
• 32 Jonathan Shore