Columbus Crew

• Goalkeeper
• 1 Eloy Room
• Defender
• 5 Milos Degenek
• 7 Pedro Santos
• 4 Mensah
• 31 Steven Moreira
• Midfielder
• 6 Darlington Nagbe
• 8 Artur 55'
• 10 Lucas Zelarrayán x2
• 22 Derrick Etienne
• 11 Luis Díaz 88'
• Forward
• 9 Cucho Hernández 90'

• Substitutes
• ent Caleb Porter 4-2-3-1
• 13 Kevin Molino
• 8 Aidan Morris (55')
• 14 Yeboah
• 24 Evan Bush
• 17 Marlon Hairston
• 23 Jalil Anibaba
• 30 Will Sands
• 19 Erik Hurtado (90')
• 26 James Igbekeme (88')

New York City

• Goalkeeper
• 1 Sean Johnson
• Defender
• 6 Callens 72'
• 12 Malte Amundsen
• 24 Tayvon Gray 56'
• 13 Thiago Martina
• Midfielder
• 43 Talles Magno
• 7 Alfredo Morales
• 11 Gabriel Segal 76'
• 20 Santiago Rodríguez
• 26 Nicolás Acevedo
• Forward
• 9 Héber 56'

• Substitutes
• ent Nick Cushing 4-2-3-1
• 8 Thiago Andrade (76')
• 4 Chanot (72')
• 3 Tinnerholm (56')
• 1 Luis Barraza
• 80 Justin Haak
• 10 Maxi Moralez (56')
• 23 Gedion Zelalem
• 2 Christopher Gloster
• 21 Andres Jasson