Philadelphia Union
- Goalkeeper
- 18 Andre Blake
- Defender
- 15 Olivier Mbaizo
- 27 Kai Wagner
- 3 Jack Elliott
- 5 Jakob Glesnes
- Midfielder
- 8 Jose Martinez
- 11 Bedoya 64'
- 31 Leon Flach
- 10 Daniel Gazdag 88'
- Forward
- 9 Julián Carranza 87'
- 7 Mikkel Uhre 71'
- Substitutes
- ent Jim Curtin 4-3-1-2
- 25 Chris Donovan
- 30 Paxten Aaronson (88')
- 19 Cory Burke (71')
- 1 Matt Freese
- 2 Matthew Real
- 16 Jack McGlynn (64')
- 34 Brandan Craig
- 26 Nathan Harriel
- 33 Quinn Sullivan (87')
Orlando City
- Goalkeeper
- 31 Mason Stajduhar
- Defender
- 25 Antonio Carlos
- 4 Joao Moutinho
- 2 Ruan 65'
- 15 Rodrigo Schlegel
- Midfielder
- 23 Jake Mulraney 45'
- 10 Pereyra 65'
- 16 Wilder Cartagena 83'
- Nicholas Gioacchini 45'
- 21 Andrés Perea
- Forward
- 19 Benji Michel
- Substitutes
- ent Óscar Pareja 4-2-3-1
- 24 Kyle Smith (65')
- 5 César Araújo (83')
- 11 Junior Urso (65')
- 17 Facundo Torres (45')
- 99 Adam Grinwis
- 13 Tesho Akindele
- 9 Ercan Kara
- 77 Iván Angulo (45')
- 26 Michael Halliday