Columbus Crew
- Goalkeeper
- 28 Patrick Schulte
- Defender
- 31 Steven Moreira
- 25 Sean Zawadzki
- 4 Rudy Camacho
- 18 Malte Amundsen 45'
- Midfielder
- 30 Hugo Picard 80'
- 7 Dylan Chambost 91'
- 27 Max Arfsten
- 16 Taha Habroune 91'
- Forward
- 10 Diego Rossi
- 8 Daniel Gazdag 62'
- Substitutes
- ent Henrik Rydström 4-4-2
- 90 Nariman Akhundzada (80')
- 14 Amar Sejdic
- 2 Andrés Herrera
- 12 Cesar Ruvalcaba
- 21 Yevhen Cheberko (45')
- 23 Mohamed Farsi (91')
- 17 Sékou Bangoura (62')
- 46 Chase Adams (91')
- 1 Nicholas Hagen
Minnesota United FC
- Goalkeeper
- 12 Drake Callender
- Defender
- 5 Nicolás Romero 74'
- 28 Jefferson Díaz
- 23 Morris Duggan
- Midfielder
- 13 Anthony Markanich
- 25 Nectarios Triantis 74'
- 3 Kyle Duncan
- 30 Owen Gene
- Forward
- 26 Joaquín Pereyra
- 9 Kelvin Yeboah x2 88'
- 8 Tomás Chancalay
- Substitutes
- ent Cameron Knowles 3-4-2-1
- 20 Will Trapp (74')
- 7 Dominik Fitz
- 1 Alec Smir
- 2 Devin Padelford
- 18 Mauricio González
- 33 Kieran Chandler
- 27 DJ Taylor
- 29 Mamadou Dieng (88')
- 15 Michael Boxall (74')