Orlando City
- Goalkeeper
- 71 Maxime Crépeau
- Defender
- 6 Robin Jansson
- 4 David Brekalo 63'
- 57 Iago Teodoro
- Midfielder
- 20 Eduard Atuesta 62'
- 8 Braian Ojeda
- 77 Iván Angulo
- 24 Griffin Dorsey 80'
- Forward
- 22 Justin Ellis 69'
- 11 Tiago 63'
- 10 Martín Ojeda x2
- Substitutes
- ent Martín Perelman 3-4-3
- 14 Tyrese Spicer (63')
- 29 Tahir Reid-Brown
- 16 Wilder Cartagena
- 87 Marco Pasalic (80')
- 13 Duncan McGuire (69')
- 12 Javier Otero
- 3 Adrián Marín (63')
- 5 Luis Otávio (62')
- 19 Zakaria Taifi
Philadelphia Union
- Goalkeeper
- 76 Andrew Rick
- Defender
- 29 Olwethu Makhanya
- 2 Geiner Martínez
- 16 Ben Bender
- 26 Nathan Harriel
- Midfielder
- 21 Danley Jean Jacques
- 14 Jeremy Rafanello
- 4 Jovan Lukic 42'
- Forward
- 19 Indiana Vassilev 64'
- 10 Milan Iloski 74'
- 9 Bruno Damiani 74'
- Substitutes
- ent Bradley Carnell 4-3-3
- 11 Bedoya
- 31 George Marks
- 66 Finn Sundstrom
- 20 Philippe Ndinga
- 15 Olivier Mbaizo
- 23 Ezekiel Alladoh (74')
- 6 Cavan Sullivan (42')
- 37 Stas Korzeniowski (74')
- 28 Augustín Anello (64')