Real Madrid’s bench problem under Álvaro Arbeloa: Why substitutes aren’t changing games
Since Arbeloa took charge, Real Madrid’s substitutes have rarely made an impact, raising questions about his in-game management and attacking options.
Real Madrid ended their game against Getafe with five forwards on the field but still failed to mount a meaningful comeback. Despite the ultra-attacking setup, Los Blancos struggled to seriously threaten goalkeeper David Soria.
Arbeloa’s substitutions failed to spark the team, continuing a worrying pattern that has developed as the former defender settles into the job. Once the coach began turning to his bench against José Bordalás’ side, Madrid managed only two shots on target. Rodrygo tested Soria in the 79th minute, and Franco Mastantuono added another attempt in the 90th.
For a team chasing the game with so many attacking players, it was a striking lack of urgency.
Predictable lineups, unpredictable substitutions
Arbeloa has been consistent with his starting lineups. Outside of injuries and suspensions, he has made very few changes from match to match.
His approach to substitutions, however, has been far harder to read.
The Madrid coach has used a wide range of strategies, but few have noticeably improved the team’s play. In tangible terms, substitutes during the Arbeloa era have produced just three assists.
Arda Güler delivered a corner that Raúl Asencio headed home against Levante. Brahim Díaz then set up goals for Vinícius Júnior and Kylian Mbappé in matches against Rayo Vallecano and Valencia. Brahim also won the stoppage-time penalty that allowed Mbappé to score the winner against Rayo.
Notably, no substitute has scored a goal under Arbeloa.
Early success at the Bernabéu
In Arbeloa’s 12 games in charge, he has used all five substitutions in seven matches.
His most successful intervention came during his home debut at the Santiago Bernabéu against Levante. At halftime, he replaced Gonzalo García and Eduardo Camavinga with Mastantuono and Güler.
The move worked, particularly with the Turkish playmaker. Güler not only provided the assist for Asencio’s goal but also took control of the game’s tempo, helping Madrid dominate possession in the second half.
Two other substitutions were forced by injuries during the Rayo Vallecano match. Brahim replaced Jude Bellingham in the 10th minute, and Dani Ceballos came on at halftime for the injured Asencio. Brahim proved decisive, assisting Vinícius and winning the penalty that Mbappé converted.
Questionable decisions in recent defeats
In other games, Arbeloa has been far more conservative.
Against Villarreal at Estadio de la Cerámica, he made only two substitutions, in the 74th and 80th minutes. During Madrid’s second visit to Benfica’s Estádio da Luz, he waited until the 86th minute before refreshing the lineup. Three changes followed, with two more arriving deep into stoppage time in the 94th and 99th minutes.
The substitutions also failed to deliver in Madrid’s last two defeats.
Against Osasuna, Arbeloa’s decision to replace Federico Valverde immediately after the Uruguayan assisted Vinícius raised eyebrows.
“He’s been making huge efforts for many games in a row and has some minor issues,” Arbeloa said after the match. “Rightly or wrongly, I preferred not to take the risk.”
Two substitutes from that game, Trent Alexander-Arnold and Ceballos, were involved in the play that led to Osasuna’s winning goal. Ceballos lost possession before Raúl García de Haro scored, while Alexander-Arnold was unable to stop the decisive finish.
Against Getafe, the coach once again turned to attack-minded substitutions, but Madrid still failed to seriously trouble Bordalás’ defense.
Substitutes see red
The most damaging moments from the bench have come in the form of red cards.
Rodrygo was sent off in the first match against Benfica, and Mastantuono followed with another dismissal Monday against Getafe. Both red cards came in stoppage time and both were for dissent toward the referee, clear signs of frustration.
Each player received a two-game suspension.
Tactical reshuffles late in games
Substitutions have also triggered several positional changes.
Valverde finished the match against Benfica playing on the left side of midfield, a role he also occupied at times against Getafe. In Monday’s game, Arbeloa resorted to a desperate 4-2-4 late on, with Valverde and Aurélien Tchouaméni anchoring midfield behind an attacking line of Mastantuono, Rodrygo, Gonzalo, and Vinícius.
The coach went even further in the closing minutes, adding Brahim for Tchouaméni and leaving Madrid with five forwards on the field.
The numbers tell the story
In total, Arbeloa has made 52 substitutions across 12 matches. Those players have accumulated roughly 1,000 minutes.
Under former coach Xabi Alonso, Madrid made 123 substitutions in 28 games, totaling 2,124 minutes. Bench players had a far greater impact during that period, contributing four goals and eight assists.
Brahim is Arbeloa’s most frequently used substitute, appearing in eight matches for 165 minutes. Nearly half of that playing time came against Rayo Vallecano, when he replaced Bellingham early in the game.
Despite his impact in that match, the Malaga-born playmaker has yet to start under the new coach, although that looks set to change against Celta Vigo on Friday, March 6.
Real Madrid: The least impactful bench in LaLiga
Real Madrid currently have the lowest contribution from substitutes in LaLiga.
According to data from BeSoccer Pro, only two of the club’s 54 league goals this season, just 3.7 percent, have been scored by players coming off the bench.
Vinícius recorded a goal and an assist as a substitute against Real Oviedo in the second round of the season. The only other league goal from a substitute came from Fran García against Real Betis in Madrid’s first match of 2026.
Two additional substitute goals arrived in the Champions League against Kairat Almaty, scored by Brahim and Camavinga.
Celta Vigo thriving with impact subs
The contrast with Real Madrid’s next opponent could not be sharper.
Celta Vigo, managed by Claudio Giráldez, rely heavily on contributions from their bench. Nearly 40 percent of the team’s LaLiga goals have been scored by substitutes.
Fourteen of Celta’s 36 league goals have come from players entering the game from the bench, with eight different players contributing. Borja Iglesias and Iago Aspas lead the group with three each. Jones El-Abdellaoui and Williot Swedberg have scored twice, while Miguel Román, Hugo Álvarez, Pablo Durán, and Javi Rueda have added one apiece.
Celta’s starters have scored 21 league goals, while Girona defender Vitor Reis also added one with an own goal in the most recent round.
Get closer to the game! Whether you like your soccer of the European variety or that of this side of the pond, our AS USA app has it all. Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more. Plus, stay updated on NFL, NBA and all other big sports stories as well as the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.
And there’s more: check out our TikTok and Instagram reels for bite-sized visual takes on all the biggest soccer news and insights.