Argentina returned home from the 2026 World Cup without the trophy, but not without an identity.

The runners-up left New York surrounded by criticism after a bruising final against Spain that featured 25 fouls, an Enzo Fernández red card, a mass confrontation after the final whistle and Argentine players turning their backs during Spain’s trophy presentation.

Outside Argentina, there was an almost unanimous view of a team that had crossed the line.

Inside Argentina, though, plenty saw something else entirely.

Argentina “dirty” antics a new badge of honor

Journalist Pedro Rosemblat summed up that mood in a viral Instagram post that has been shared thousands of times since the final. Rather than apologizing, he argued that Argentina’s critics simply cannot stomach what he called the country’s “irreverence.”

He listed the nations celebrating Spain’s victory, claimed critics had spent the tournament accusing Argentina of buying refereeing decisions and favorable treatment from FIFA, and argued that labels such as “cocky,” “cheaters” and “dirty” had become badges of honor rather than insults.

His conclusion was simple: “We love it.”

Argentina: a country that sees criticism as respect

That attitude helps explain why the international backlash has seemingly barely dented morale at home.

“We’ve always been criticized,” fan Maximiliano Heredia told AFP while welcoming the team back to Buenos Aires. “We’re used to it. But we always give it our all.”

Lawyer Leo Simone offered a similar view, arguing that outsiders mistake Argentine pride for arrogance.

“They confuse arrogance with pride,” his wife added during the AFP interview.

Rosemblat’s message struck the same chord. He portrayed Argentina as a country that succeeds despite having fewer resources than many of its rivals and suggested that being disliked comes with consistently competing for soccer’s biggest prizes.

While the Spanish national teams – reigning men’s World, European and Olympic Champions, women’s World Champions, and multiple junior champions – may suggest otherwise, it is a narrative many Argentines happily embrace.

Not everyone believes Argentina criticism is unfair

That does not mean there is complete agreement.

Veteran sports journalist Ezequiel Fernández Moores told AFP that Argentina’s culture of provocation and boasting often fails to translate internationally and admitted the players turning their backs during Spain’s trophy lift “wasn’t right.”

The criticism has also extended beyond gamesmanship.

Argentina has continued to face scrutiny over racist incidents involving supporters, including FIFA’s condemnation after a fan directed racist abuse at streamer IShowSpeed during the tournament. Sociologist Iván Schuliaquer said those incidents should not be ignored, while cautioning against using them to define an entire country.

For many Argentines, though, the rest of the debate barely matters. If the football world wants a villain, they seem perfectly happy to play the part.

Get closer to the game! Whether you like your soccer of the European variety or that on this side of the pond, our AS USA app has it all. Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more. Plus, stay updated on NFL, NBA and all other big sports stories as well as the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.

And there’s more: check out our TikTok and Instagram reels for bite-sized visual takes on all the biggest soccer news and insights.