| Pos. | Team | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Herediano
Costa Rica
|
100Percentage of goals coming from penalties |
Houston Dynamo
United States of America
|
100 | |
Orlando City
United States of America
|
100 | |
| 2 |
América
Mexico
|
53.33 |
| 3 |
Real Estelí
Nicaragua
|
50 |
| 4 |
Saprissa
Costa Rica
|
33.33 |
| 5 |
New England Revolution
United States of America
|
25 |
Tigres
Mexico
|
25 | |
| 6 |
Pachuca
Mexico
|
16.67 |
| 7 |
Alajuelense
Costa Rica
|
0 |
Columbus Crew
United States of America
|
0 | |
Comunicaciones
Guatemala
|
0 | |
FC Cincinnati
United States of America
|
0 | |
Forge
Canada
|
0 | |
Chivas
Mexico
|
0 | |
Inter Miami CF
United States of America
|
0 | |
Rayados
Mexico
|
0 | |
Nashville SC
United States of America
|
0 | |
Philadelphia Union
United States of America
|
0 | |
St. Louis City SC
United States of America
|
0 | |
Toluca
Mexico
|
0 | |
Vancouver Whitecaps
United States of America
|
0 | |
Cavalry FC
Canada
|
0 | |
Robinhood
Suriname
|
0 |
