On Arbor Day we take a look back at Bill Gates’ remarks on planting trees to mitigate climate change: “complete nonsense”

Arbor Day has always been a little idealistic, but in a good way, I’d say. It basically asks people to plant something they may never see fully grown. When it began in Nebraska in 1872, more than a million trees reportedly went into the ground in a single day. The premise was simple: do something small, and trust that it adds up over time.

That spirit has survived in some places. Schools still hand kids saplings. Cities still mark the day with speeches about shade, clean air and future generations. It is one of the few rituals that feels uncomplicated and kind. In a world where certain powerful leaders are focused on everything for themselves, it’s comfortingly selfless.

Which is why Bill Gates’ comment, dropped into a week of climate panels a few years back, sounded so out of sync. The idea that planting enough trees could solve climate change, he said, was “complete nonsense.” Then came the sharper line: “Are we science people or are we idiots?”

Gates’ blunt message sparks debate

The reaction tends to split people in predictable ways. Some hear arrogance. Others hear relief that someone is willing to say the quiet part out loud. Because buried inside the provocation is a point that is difficult to argue with: trees help, but they do not replace cutting emissions.

There is a temptation, especially in public campaigns, to reach for solutions that feel tangible. A tree is visible. You can point to it, water it, take a photo next to it. “Look what I’ve done to help the planet!”

Carbon reduction is messier. It involves grids, fuels, supply chains, policy battles. It’s definitely harder to turn into a school activity.

Gates has spent years arguing that the real work sits there, in the less photogenic parts, and his investments reflect that. Advanced nuclear through TerraPower. Carbon capture. Industrial innovation that most people will never see up close. Even his optimism about climate tends to come with conditions: emissions must peak, then fall, and technology has to scale in ways it has not yet managed.

Is Arbor Day worth it?

Of course, that doesn’t make Arbor Day, ahem, hollow. It’s just a reminder that the challenge remains huge and wide-ranging. Trees cool cities. They reduce flood risk. They make places liveable in ways spreadsheets struggle to measure. In some regions, they even store meaningful amounts of carbon. They really matter. Gates’ phrasing was deliberately jarring, maybe more than necessary, but it forced the issue into the open again.

So, please, go and plant the trees whenever you can. Support local projects. It’s a good thing and can help. Just don’t confuse the act with a solution that can carry the whole weight of the climate problem.

Get closer to the game! Whether you like your soccer of the European variety or that on this side of the pond, our AS USA app has it all. Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more. Plus, stay updated on NFL, NBA and all other big sports stories as well as the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.

And there’s more: check out our TikTok and Instagram reels for bite-sized visual takes on all the biggest soccer news and insights.