England are back in another World Cup semifinal, with their good old friends Argentina waiting for them on Wednesday. The results keep coming. The deep tournament runs keep piling up. And yet, somehow, the conversation always ends up in exactly the same place.

“We haven’t played our best football yet.”

It has become one of the defining themes of England at major tournaments. Not because Harry Kane’s words after scraping through against Norway in this 2026 World Cup quarterfinal are still fresh in my ears, but because it feels like the same promise has been hanging in the air for the best part of a decade.

The breakthrough is coming. The real England is just around the corner. Next game will be different.

Maybe this time they’re right. Then again, we’ve heard it before.

Can England find that performance?

The latest version came after England booked another place in the last four.

“We’re in the semi-finals of the World Cup and we haven’t played our best football yet. If we can show that on Wednesday, it could make the difference between winning and losing this tournament,” Kane said after the win over Norway.

Thomas Tuchel hardly disagreed. He praised England’s mentality but admitted they would have to play better if they were going to become world champions. “Sloppy” and “lucky” were even thrown in.

And it’s hardly a new message.

Two years ago at Euro 2024, after a disappointing draw with Denmark, Kane insisted there was no reason to panic.

“We know we can improve. I know there’ll probably be loads of noise and a bit of disappointment back home, but we experienced this in the last Euros as well.”

A few moments later he added another line that could almost serve as the motto for modern England tournament football.

“We have to improve with and without the ball.”

Nobody really argued with that.

England’s favourite tournament tradition?

The funny thing is this isn’t just something the players say. It has almost become an annual tradition among managers, journalists and pundits too. Open any national newspaper or turn on sport radio and the optimism is consistent.

Whenever the Three Lions grind out another result, somebody inevitably suggests they’re conserving energy, building gradually or waiting for the later rounds before revealing their best football. And I get it. Just look at the parts, if not the sum of them.

Euro 2024 was probably the clearest example.

England stumbled through the group stage. Then came Jude Bellingham’s spectacular overhead kick against Slovakia in stoppage time to spare blushes. Then penalties against Switzerland. Then Ollie Watkins’ dramatic late winner against the Netherlands.

At almost every step there was a sense that England, jam-packed with millionaire household names – hadn’t really clicked yet – but surely they would in the next match.

That next match turned out to be the final. Spain won that.

England’s ‘it’s coming soon’ script

Go back to Qatar in 2022 and the narrative feels strangely familiar.

After the goalless draw with the United States, Harry Kane shrugged off the outside criticism.

“It’s not the end of the world.”

Gareth Southgate struck a similar tone, insisting there was “no need for everybody to be so despondent.”

England then produced one of their best displays of the tournament against Senegal before narrowly losing to France.

Good? Absolutely. But it still wasn’t the sustained run of dominant football many had spent weeks predicting.

You can trace similar themes back to Russia in 2018 and Euro 2020. The wording changed, but the message rarely did. England were learning. England were growing. England were still improving.

The best was always waiting just ahead.

Maybe that’s just who England are

Perhaps this isn’t a flaw at all.

Since 2018, England have reached a World Cup semifinal, a European Championship final, a World Cup quarterfinal, another European Championship final and now another World Cup semifinal.

Most countries would trade places in an instant.

Maybe England don’t need to “click.” Maybe this version – disciplined, resilient and occasionally dramatic – is simply their identity. More about standout player moments than the cohesion and control that some other major nations have.

Still, it’s hard not to smile at how familiar the conversation has become.

Another tournament.

Another semifinal.

Another promise that the best performance is only one game away. And if the long wait ends at 60 years, nobody will care about how it happened.

Get closer to the game! Whether you like your soccer of the European variety or that on this side of the pond, our AS USA app has it all. Dive into live coverage, expert insights, breaking news, exclusive videos, and more. Plus, stay updated on NFL, NBA and all other big sports stories as well as the latest in current affairs and entertainment. Download now for all-access coverage, right at your fingertips – anytime, anywhere.

And there’s more: check out our TikTok and Instagram reels for bite-sized visual takes on all the biggest soccer news and insights.